HOME > PUBLICATIONS > HARD TIMES
Hard Times
A research report into hill farming and farming families in the Peak District

REPORT EXPOSES TRAGEDY OF PEAK DISTRICT £2.50 / HOUR FARMERS

Peak District hill farmers are among the most deprived in the country, earning just £7,482 per year for a gruelling 58 hour working week.

This equates to earning about £2.50p an hour, nearly £2 below the legal minimum hourly wage level and around the cost of eight pints of milk bought from a supermarket.

The research report, Hard Times, commissioned by the Peak District Rural Deprivation Forum and funded by Oxfam, looked at income levels among hill farmers in the Peak District and the impact of government policy on the quality of life of farming families.


Shockingly, the annual income includes subsidies provided by government. Without government

subsidy these farmers would be in debt to the tune of £2,300 each year. The report also finds that their farm incomes have dropped by 75% over the last 10 years with incomes over 2002 being a quarter of what they were in 1992.

PDRDF spokesperson Carol Evans said: "It's shameful that many of Derbyshire's food producers are living on the breadline - earning far less than the legal minimum wage.

A myth still persists that all farmers are rich and greedy - this report makes clear that nothing could be further from the truth."

Britain's lowest paid workers in cleaning, catering and security jobs can all earn significantly more than the Peak District's poorest farmers. Many farmers can't afford to hire casual labourers to help on their farm so are working long hours for very little pay."

The shocking reality is that farmers feel persecuted, isolated and undervalued."

Not only are these farmers responsible for providing the nation with food, they are also responsible for maintaining and managing the landscape and making it accessible to people who enjoy visiting the countryside.

Carol Evans continued: "If hill farming dies out in this country who will be there to manage the landscape for us all to enjoy? The pleasant Sunday walk in the country could become a thing of the past.

Peak District farmers want to keep farming but hardship and poverty is forcing them to give up their jobs and sell their land."


The research for 'Hard Times' was carried out between 2001 and 2003 and includes 12 qualitative case studies describing the day-to-day experiences of farmers and data unique to a hill farming area

Contents - HARD TIMES Pg
Forward 4
Executive Summary 5
Chapter 1 Background to Research 8
Chapter 2 Research : Case Studies and Data  
  Part 1 : Farming Case Studies in the Peak District (Chris Higgins) 10
  Introduction 10
  Project Framework 10
  Interview Focus 11
  Parameters of the average 11
  A Caricature of Peak District Farming from the Case Studies 13
  Issue Specific Responses 14
    1. The principles of enjoyment and discontentment in farming 14
    2. Perceived route to improved farm income 15
    3. Impact of increased bureaucracy 16
    4. Impact of market closures 16
    5. Impact of small abattoir closures 17
    6. Perceptions of standards application internationally 17
    7. Farm diversification 18
    8. Co-operation 19
    9. Reflections on the outbreak of Foot and Mouth disease 20
    10. The right to roam 21
    11. Farming and future generations 22
    12. Stress 23
    13. Social isolation 24
    14. Confidence in continued farming 25
    15. Routes to influence policy 26
    16. Additional observations 28
  Implications of the case study findings 29
Part 2 : Farming Incomes in the Peak District National Park (Martin Seabrook) 30
Part 3 : Conclusions of Chris Higgins and Martin Seabrook 36
Chapter 3 Conclusions and Recommendations of the Farming Working Group 39
Appendices 47


TOP